For Sale
$ 998,500
c. 1868 Second Empire Victorian
6445 West Maple Grove Road
Ellettsville, Indiana 47429
Ellettsville, Indiana 47429
The Matthews Mansion
;void(null))
An Historic 1800s Home Thoughtfully Restored for Modern Living
Own a timeless piece of Indiana’s heritage.
Built between 1862 and 1878 by John Matthews—founder of Indiana’s limestone industry—this French Second Empire masterpiece is one of the Midwest’s most architecturally significant homes.
Construction began during the Civil War and stretched over 16 years, reflecting both the turbulent era and Matthews’ vision for a lasting legacy. The estate served not only as his family home, but as a proud symbol of the booming limestone trade he helped pioneer.
Crafted from 22-inch-thick hand-carved limestone, the home features a slate mansard roof, ornate iron cresting, and a limestone veranda adorned with four carved stone faces—believed to represent Matthews’ children.
Local legend ties the home’s design to Charles Garnier, famed architect of the Paris Opera House, adding to its mystique.
Inside, historic elegance meets modern functionality:
- 12’ ceilings, original walnut trim, and three working fireplaces
- Etched red and blue glass transoms and restored horsehair plaster
- Fully renovated kitchen with soapstone counters and smart home features
- Spa-inspired primary suite, custom closets, and wine cellar with hidden door
Set on 2.76 private acres, the property also features a limestone firepit, barnwood garage and shed, and beautifully restored landscaping.
Listed on the National Register of Historic Places and part of the Matthews Stone Company Historic District, this estate has had only four owners since 1955.
The Matthews Mansion is more than a home—it's a rare opportunity to own a story written in stone.
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
;void(null))
| 3 Stories | |
| Bedrooms | 3 |
| Full Baths | 2 |
| Half Baths | 1 |
| Heated Sq. Ft. | 3,686 |
| Acres | 2.8 |
| Property Taxes |
| $9,090 |
| MLS No. | 202516067 |
Features.
- Built-in Bookcases
- Ceiling Fans
- Gas Logs
- Grand staircase
- High Ceilings
- Walk-In Closet(s)
- Walk-in Shower(s)
- Central air
- City sewer
- City water supply
- Dishwasher
- Gas heating
- Refrigerator
- 12-foot Ceilings
- Plaster Walls
Like This Listing?
Contact the Agent directly.
REMAX Acclaimed Properties
Chris Smith
Broker/Owner
Mobile: 812 219-3030
Phone: 812 558-6570
listings@chrissmith3030.com
Tell 'em you saw it on OldHouses.com!
Comments & Feedback
All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. OldHouses.com is not responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.
OldHouses.com headquarters, Union, SC.
;newwin.creator=self;newwin.focus();void(null)){kind=link}
;newwin.creator=self;newwin.focus();void(null)){kind=link}