OldHouses.com logo

Listing No. 4765

More Old Houses

From The Archives

c. 1825 Federal

Castalia, North Carolina

The Arrington House

The Arrington family were some of the earliest settlers of Nash Co., NC. Arthur Arrington (1709-1779) was born in VA and emigrated from there to present-day Nash Co. around 1760, and his great-grandson Lewellyn was born there in 1792. Lewellyn inherited, purchased or constructed a single room structure (probably with a small loft or attic above) on the south bank of Sandy Creek around 1820, and around 1825, when he married Sally Bunn, he expanded this structure into a typical house of the time, with two rooms flanking a center hall downstairs, and two bedrooms upstairs. (The single room structure mentioned above is now the dining room of the house.)
Scroll down for more information
Sandy Creek
Sandy Creek
Approx. 2000' frontage on pristine Sandy Creek.
The property contains about 50 acres, with about 15 acres cleared,and would be perfect for a horse farm, small winery, etc..
Dining room
Dining room
All woodwork is original.
Living room
Living room
Entry foyer
Entry foyer
A 19th century log home that was added to the south end of the house in the 1992 restoration.
All modern stainless steel appliances. Countertops and stove backsplash of Italian terra cotta tile.
Adjacent building
Adjacent building
Pre-1850 farmhouse, with 2 rooms on 1st floor semi-restored. Adjacent to main house. Used as weaver's studio by previous owner, can be fully restored or used as workshop/storage.
Upstairs bedroom
Upstairs bedroom
Upstairs are two bedrooms and a full bath.
Herb Garden
Herb Garden
Near the house is a fenced-in herb and perennial garden.
Garden Cat
Garden Cat
We might even throw in a spoiled garden cat.
Bedrooms 4
Full Baths 3
Heated Sq. Ft. 3,543
Stories 2
Acres 49


  • 1st Floor Bath
  • 1st Floor Bedroom
  • 1st Floor Laundry Room
  • Attic
  • Crawl Space
  • Den
  • Dining room
  • Entry Hall
  • Kitchen
  • Barn
  • Garden
  • Rear Deck
  • 2nd Staircase
  • Fireplaces
  • High Ceilings
  • Wood floors
  • Tin Roof
  • Central air
  • Dishwasher
  • Heat pump
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Septic Tank
  • Water Heater - Electric

No Contact Information.

This listing is archived and is not for sale.

Contact information is not available for archived listings.

The Arrington House

Lewellyn’s son Benjamin was born in 1828, and inherited the house when Lewellyn died in 1860. Benjamin became a successful farmer, owning over 4000 acres. In 1861 Benjamin enlisted in the Confederate Army (Co. I, 15th NC Infantry) and in 1863 when his term of service expired, he returned home and married Rebecca Pitts, and together they raised three children, Samuel (b. 1875), Cornelia (b. 1881) and Henry (b. 1888). Son Henry inherited the house and upon his death in 1959 it was sold outside of the Arrington family and occupied by a series of renters.

By the 1970’s it had fallen into a state of disrepair and became unoccupied until it was purchased in 1990 by Bob and Emily Hyatt. The Hyatts moved the house and the plantation office (a separate structure) to a new location about a mile away (also on Sandy Creek) and began an extensive and careful restoration of the house, joining the old plantation office to the north end of the main house to serve as a bedroom. They then purchased two other nearby structures, a pre-1850 farmhouse and a 19th century log cabin, and moved them both to the property. The log cabin was attached to the south end of the house and turned into a library/study, and the farmhouse was placed nearby, and the two rooms on the first floor of the farmhouse semi-restored. Emily Hyatt is a nationally-known weaver who has been featured in Time and Southern Living magazines, and she used this pre-1850 farmhouse as her studio, and as a place to demonstrate her weaving to groups of schoolchildren who came out to learn about early weaving techniques.

The house today is in a wonderful state of preservation, and combines all the charm and personality of a house that has sheltered many generations of families, with all modern systems, i.e., plumbing, wiring, heat pumps, etc.. There are two fully-functioning fireplaces and a high-efficiency Jotul woodstove. The main part of the house is heated and cooled by a state of the art Trane heat pump (rated 14 SEER), installed August, 2008. It is located on a beautiful and rolling tract of approximately 50 acres (with about 1/3 cleared) and the longest property line (almost 1/2 mile—about 2000 ft) is pristine Sandy Creek, which has been declared an “outstanding resource water zone” (the state's highest ranking) due to its exceptional cleanliness and the fact that two endangered species of mussels are found there. Mink, beavers, otters and bobcats have all been spotted around the creek, and deer, wild turkeys and even the occasional bald eagle are a common sight around the property. Landscaping includes a fenced-in herb and perennial garden.

The property is located off of a state-maintained gravel road and is exceptionally quiet and secluded, yet is within an easy 50 minute commute to downtown Raleigh (using Highway 64) and is 20 minutes from Rocky Mount.

Rooms include a large central hallway measuring 17'3" x 7'9". Living room is 19'5" x 17'3" and includes a working fireplace and permanent staircase to the second floor. Across the center hall is a formal dining room that measures 19'2" x 17'4" also with a working fireplace and a staircase to the second-floor bedroom and bath area also. The kitchen and family room measures 46'3" x 23'4" and was originally the back porch of the main structure. The first floor bedroom measures 11'9x15'4 with a full bath off hallway. This part of the structure was originally the plantation office and was moved to this property and attached to the house during the 1992 restoration.

A separate laundry and pantry can be found just off the back hallway before entering the kitchen. Beside it is a spacious office and/or entertaining room, suitable for guests or a family gathering, including a wet bar.

The log cabin room is adjacent; it measures 19'8" x 19'2" and has an outside exit on the right side of the house (easy access outside to the herb garden or the pre-1850 farmhouse, partially renovated, which is also included on the property). The main house boasts a second master bedroom. This room measures 20' x 16'2" with private bath. There is a total of four bedrooms and three full baths featured in this home, with all baths updated in 2008.

The views are spectacular, and each room offers many different views of natural animal habitat. With the acreage available, this property could be used as a horse farm or even a small winery.

Archived in January, 2013

Comments & Feedback

All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. OldHouses.com is not responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.

Listing No. 4765

More Old Houses

Your Feedback

Help & Support.

Return to Top