OldHouses.com logo

For Sale

$ 650,000

Listing No. 38140

1849 Colonial
Mussertown
Lancaster, PA









Historic Sunday School Transfomed into Modern Lancaster Living

Nearly 175 years ago, a local congregation built a Sunday School overlooking the City of Lancaster. A century later, this same structure became a place of worship for the community. Today, 14 E. Farnum Street begins a new chapter—beautifully transformed into a meticulously restored single-story urban residence in historic Old Town Lancaster.

From the moment you arrive, the grandeur of this home is undeniable. Locally crafted eight-foot mahogany doors open into a gracious foyer, where 12-foot ceilings, warm brass sconces, and refined crown molding set the tone for the home’s sophisticated yet inviting style.

The kitchen and dining area blend artistry with function, featuring Monogram appliances, Wellborn cabinetry, and gorgeous marble countertops—perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. The guest bath is a showcase of Carrara marble and design elegance, complemented by a spacious walk-in shower. The guest bedroom, with its built-in designer wardrobe, offers both comfort and architectural charm.

The primary suite continues the home’s theme of understated luxury, highlighted by chandelier lighting and dual professionally designed closets. The ensuite bath features individual vanities, Carrara marble, and a distinguished walk-in shower—creating a serene retreat. Step through the mahogany French doors to a private courtyard, an urban oasis that invites calm and connection.

With convenient street parking and nearby off-street options, this home provides effortless access to all that downtown Lancaster has to offer. This remarkable property represents a rare opportunity to experience historic craftsmanship perfectly reimagined for modern living.
Bedrooms: 2
Full Bath(s): 2
Heated Sq. Ft.: 1,653
Lot Size: 2,614 sqft

Contact the Agent directly.

Anne Lusk photo Anne Lusk

Phone: 717-291-9101

Website: www.AnneLusk.com

Tell 'em you saw it on OldHouses.com!

Features.

  • 1st floor bath
  • 1st Floor Bedroom
  • 1st floor laundry room
  • Entry Hall
  • Foyer
  • Gourmet Kitchen
  • Living room
  • Primary bedroom downstairs
  • Built-in Cabinets
  • Ceramic Tile
  • High Ceilings
  • Walk-In Closet(s)
  • Walk-in Shower(s)
  • Wood floors
  • Shingle Roof
  • Central air
  • City sewer
  • City water supply
  • Dishwasher
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • French doors
  • Gourmet kitchen

To view this listing go to:
www.oldhouses.com/38140

All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. OldHouses.com is not responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.

©2026 Copley Internet Systems, Inc.