For Sale
1870 Colonial
Middletown, New York 10941
The "Captain's Quarters"

The original log home built in 1724 sat on the foundation, but was removed in 1904 by a team of oxen pulling it over huge logs! Elizabeth "Lizzy" Bull had the existing two-story house built atop the original foundation. The exterior walls are 2 1/2 feet thick and were professionally repointed and are comprised of fieldstone and Franklinite.
This 3-bedroom home offers all of its original details including hand-hewn beams, Cypress woodwork, plaster and lathe walls, slate roof, original chandeliers, hardwood flooring throughout and even a 'sewing room' once used for storing traveling trunks.
This unique stone home is situated on 8 private and wooded acres with views from the wrap-around porch of the fields and Wallkill River. It's located on a quiet country road, yet minutes to all shopping, roadways, medical facilities, Stewart International Airport, Mohonk Mountain House, West Point, hiking and biking trails, restaurants and so much more! Valley Central schools! Own a piece of history!
Bedrooms | 3 |
Full Baths | 1 |
Heated Sq. Ft. | 2,450 |
Acres | 8.1 |
MLS No. | H6174805 |
Features.
- Carport
- Deck
- Storage Building
- Fireplaces
- Slate Roof
- Wood floors
- Stained woodwork/doors
- Vintage Light Fixtures
- Wrap-Around Porch
- Bidet
- Trunk room
Like This Listing?
Contact the Agent directly.
RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group
Patricia Sassi
Mobile: 845-800-3937
Tell 'em you saw it on OldHouses.com!
Comments & Feedback
All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. OldHouses.com is not responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.